
August 10, 2019. Jeffrey Epstein, the wealthy financier awaiting trial on federal sex trafficking charges, is found dead in his cell at a Manhattan federal jail.
The New York City medical examiner rules it a suicide by hanging.
For seven years, that has been the official answer. But it has never stopped the questions.
Now a forensic expert says he has the evidence to back them up.
"Strangled From Behind"
On Monday, Nov. 16, Dr. Michael Freeman, a consultant in forensic medicine who has testified as an expert in high-profile court cases, presented his findings in London. He worked alongside Swedish forensic pathologist Anders Eriksson and cognitive neuroscientist Itiel Dror.
After reviewing the full autopsy file and previously unpublished autopsy photos, the team says it found no evidence that a hanging took place. Instead, they say Epstein's injuries are consistent with an assault and a struggle.
Freeman pointed to what appear to be fingernail marks above the ligature mark on Epstein's neck, which he said "would be consistent with strangulation, particularly from behind."
How He Reached His Conclusion
Freeman reportedly spent more than a year studying the case. Using the autopsy photos, he built a 3-D model of the injuries to Epstein's neck and used it to test whether they matched a suicide by hanging.
He also pointed to an orange piece of fabric found in Epstein's cell, which he says may support his theory.
For Freeman, the question isn't whether Epstein was killed. As he told CBS News: "Was this a suicide? Not a mystery." He says the real mystery is who did it.
The photos were provided by Epstein's brother, Mark, who has long disputed the suicide ruling. Freeman says his analysis is independent and that he wasn't paid by Mark Epstein.
The Official Ruling Hasn't Changed
The New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner isn't backing down. In a statement to CNN, the office said it "stands by its determination" that Epstein died by suicide and that the manner was hanging.
The medical examiner who performed the autopsy told Justice Department investigators that Epstein's injuries were more consistent with suicide by hanging than homicide by strangulation, and that there were no defensive wounds typically seen in strangulation victims.
Several federal investigations have also concluded that Epstein hanged himself. Records show he had been briefly placed on suicide watch about a month before his death.
It's also important to note that Freeman's findings have not been peer reviewed, and forensic pathology is not an exact science.
Not the First Expert to Raise Doubts
Freeman is the second outside expert to challenge the suicide ruling. In 2020, Mark Epstein hired well-known forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden, who also concluded, based on the evidence he reviewed, that Epstein was likely murdered. Baden pointed to fractures in Epstein's neck.
Doubts have swirled since the beginning. A Justice Department inspector general report later blamed serious failures by jail staff the night Epstein died, but still found he died by suicide.
What Happens Now?
For now, nothing official changes. Epstein's death remains classified as a suicide, and federal authorities have announced no plans to reopen the investigation.
But the new analysis is sure to add fuel to one of the most enduring debates of the decade.
Seven years later, the official ruling still says suicide. One forensic expert says the evidence says something else. The question of what really happened in that cell is far from settled.














