A Historic Vermont Mill Retreat Right on the Creek

Originally rooted in the 1790s and set directly on the rushing waters of Lewis Creek in Starksboro, Vermont, this two-bedroom historic mill retreat is the kind of property people dream about and almost never find. Reclaimed wood, original stone, cascading water, decks overlooking natural rock formations, and no need whatsoever for a white noise machine. Reddit loves it. The tax assessment, however, has raised some eyebrows.

Vermont History, Preserved and Livable

This 1,656-square-foot, two-bed, two-bath home blends historic character with comfortable year-round living. The open-concept interior is designed to pull in the creekside surroundings at every turn, with reclaimed wood and original stone carrying the architectural story of a building that has stood on Lewis Creek for over two centuries. Outside, decks and outdoor spaces overlook cascading water and natural rock formations in a setting that feels genuinely private and restorative. The property has previously served as both a successful seasonal rental and an intimate wedding venue — which makes a certain amount of sense, because it is objectively beautiful. Thoughtful updates provide modern comfort without disturbing the authentic character throughout.

Gorgeous Setting, Ambitious Ask

Tucked away in Starksboro yet roughly 30 minutes from Burlington, Middlebury, and Waterbury, the location is genuinely serene without being impractical. Reddit is universally charmed — one commenter said they'd live there in a heartbeat if money were no object. The sticking point, as another noted, is the tax assessment sitting at $350,000 against a $775,000 ask, which suggests the sellers are carrying some high hopes into this listing. Whether the setting justifies the gap is, as always, in the eye of the buyer. The creek, for its part, is not negotiating.

The Internet Has Thoughts

Naturally, this listing caught the attention of Reddit's r/zillowgonewild community. See what people are saying about it here.

A 230-year-old Vermont mill retreat on a rushing creek, previously used as a wedding venue — this one is genuinely one of a kind. View the full listing here.