This Charming Small-Town Maine Colonial Comes With a Genuine Jump Scare

On paper, this $259,000 Colonial in Dexter, Maine checks every box: five bedrooms, two baths, 2,256 square feet, direct ATV and snowmobile trail access, and a spot in the heart of a proud small town. Then you scroll through the photos. One Reddit poster summed it up perfectly: "Was not expecting the jumpscare I got from this beautiful old house."

The House Itself Is Genuinely Lovely

Set in Dexter — known locally as "The Heart of Maine" and centered around Lake Wassookeag — this updated Colonial pairs classic New England character with modern comforts: a roof under transferable lifetime warranty, a freshly painted exterior, and a spacious yard with room to garden or entertain. It's the kind of listing that quietly sells itself on charm and location alone.

Except for the Dolls

A substantial doll collection fills several rooms of the home in the listing photos, and Reddit had a field day with it — comparing the vibe to a Stephen King setting, joking about hidden crawl space residents, and questioning whether the listing agent should have edited a few of them out. It's the kind of detail that makes a perfectly nice house genuinely hard to look away from, for better or worse.

The Internet Has Thoughts

Naturally, this listing caught the attention of Reddit's r/zillowgonewild community. See what people are saying about it here.

Trail access, small-town charm, and a doll collection you won't forget. View the full listing here.